A comparative investigation of the combined effects of pre-processing, wavelength selection, and regression methods on near-infrared calibration model performance

Jian Wan, Yi-Chieh Chen, A. Julian Morris, Suresh N. Thennadil

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy is being widely used in various fields ranging from pharmaceutics to the food industry for analyzing chemical and physical properties of the substances concerned. Its advantages over other analytical techniques include available physical interpretation of spectral data, nondestructive nature and high speed of measurements, and little or no need for sample preparation. The successful application of NIR spectroscopy relies on three main aspects: pre-processing of spectral data to eliminate nonlinear variations due to temperature, light scattering effects and many others, selection of those wavelengths that contribute useful information, and identification of suitable calibration models using linear/nonlinear regression . Several methods have been developed for each of these three aspects and many comparative studies of different methods exist for an individual aspect or some combinations. However, there is still a lack of comparative studies for the interactions among these three aspects, which can shed light on what role each aspect plays in the calibration and how to combine various methods of each aspect together to obtain the best calibration model. This paper aims to provide such a comparative study based on four benchmark data sets using three typical pre-processing methods, namely, orthogonal signal correction (OSC), extended multiplicative signal correction (EMSC) and optical path-length estimation and correction (OPLEC); two existing wavelength selection methods, namely, stepwise forward selection (SFS) and genetic algorithm optimization combined with partial least squares regression for spectral data (GAPLSSP); four popular regression methods, namely, partial least squares (PLS), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), least squares support vector machine (LS-SVM), and Gaussian process regression (GPR). The comparative study indicates that, in general, pre-processing of spectral data can play a significant role in the calibration while wavelength selection plays a marginal role and the combination of certain pre-processing, wavelength selection, and nonlinear regression methods can achieve superior performance over traditional linear regression-based calibration.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1432-1446
Number of pages15
JournalApplied Spectroscopy
Volume71
Issue number7
Early online date30 Mar 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2017

Fingerprint

preprocessing
regression analysis
Calibration
Infrared radiation
Wavelength
Processing
wavelengths
Near infrared spectroscopy
infrared spectroscopy
Linear regression
Light scattering
Chemical properties
Support vector machines
optical paths
Identification (control systems)
shrinkage
food
genetic algorithms
chemical properties
Physical properties

Keywords

  • near-infrared spectroscopy
  • scatter correction
  • pre-processing
  • wavelength selection
  • regression
  • multivariate calibration
  • support vector machines
  • Gaussian process regression
  • partial least squares regression
  • PLS

Cite this

@article{ab3aa88e64de41428130d14e79d04342,
title = "A comparative investigation of the combined effects of pre-processing, wavelength selection, and regression methods on near-infrared calibration model performance",
abstract = "Near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy is being widely used in various fields ranging from pharmaceutics to the food industry for analyzing chemical and physical properties of the substances concerned. Its advantages over other analytical techniques include available physical interpretation of spectral data, nondestructive nature and high speed of measurements, and little or no need for sample preparation. The successful application of NIR spectroscopy relies on three main aspects: pre-processing of spectral data to eliminate nonlinear variations due to temperature, light scattering effects and many others, selection of those wavelengths that contribute useful information, and identification of suitable calibration models using linear/nonlinear regression . Several methods have been developed for each of these three aspects and many comparative studies of different methods exist for an individual aspect or some combinations. However, there is still a lack of comparative studies for the interactions among these three aspects, which can shed light on what role each aspect plays in the calibration and how to combine various methods of each aspect together to obtain the best calibration model. This paper aims to provide such a comparative study based on four benchmark data sets using three typical pre-processing methods, namely, orthogonal signal correction (OSC), extended multiplicative signal correction (EMSC) and optical path-length estimation and correction (OPLEC); two existing wavelength selection methods, namely, stepwise forward selection (SFS) and genetic algorithm optimization combined with partial least squares regression for spectral data (GAPLSSP); four popular regression methods, namely, partial least squares (PLS), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), least squares support vector machine (LS-SVM), and Gaussian process regression (GPR). The comparative study indicates that, in general, pre-processing of spectral data can play a significant role in the calibration while wavelength selection plays a marginal role and the combination of certain pre-processing, wavelength selection, and nonlinear regression methods can achieve superior performance over traditional linear regression-based calibration.",
keywords = "near-infrared spectroscopy, scatter correction, pre-processing, wavelength selection, regression, multivariate calibration, support vector machines, Gaussian process regression, partial least squares regression, PLS",
author = "Jian Wan and Yi-Chieh Chen and Morris, {A. Julian} and Thennadil, {Suresh N.}",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/0003702817694623",
language = "English",
volume = "71",
pages = "1432--1446",
journal = "Applied Spectroscopy",
issn = "0003-7028",
number = "7",

}

A comparative investigation of the combined effects of pre-processing, wavelength selection, and regression methods on near-infrared calibration model performance. / Wan, Jian; Chen, Yi-Chieh; Morris, A. Julian; Thennadil, Suresh N.

In: Applied Spectroscopy, Vol. 71, No. 7, 01.07.2017, p. 1432-1446.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparative investigation of the combined effects of pre-processing, wavelength selection, and regression methods on near-infrared calibration model performance

AU - Wan, Jian

AU - Chen, Yi-Chieh

AU - Morris, A. Julian

AU - Thennadil, Suresh N.

PY - 2017/7/1

Y1 - 2017/7/1

N2 - Near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy is being widely used in various fields ranging from pharmaceutics to the food industry for analyzing chemical and physical properties of the substances concerned. Its advantages over other analytical techniques include available physical interpretation of spectral data, nondestructive nature and high speed of measurements, and little or no need for sample preparation. The successful application of NIR spectroscopy relies on three main aspects: pre-processing of spectral data to eliminate nonlinear variations due to temperature, light scattering effects and many others, selection of those wavelengths that contribute useful information, and identification of suitable calibration models using linear/nonlinear regression . Several methods have been developed for each of these three aspects and many comparative studies of different methods exist for an individual aspect or some combinations. However, there is still a lack of comparative studies for the interactions among these three aspects, which can shed light on what role each aspect plays in the calibration and how to combine various methods of each aspect together to obtain the best calibration model. This paper aims to provide such a comparative study based on four benchmark data sets using three typical pre-processing methods, namely, orthogonal signal correction (OSC), extended multiplicative signal correction (EMSC) and optical path-length estimation and correction (OPLEC); two existing wavelength selection methods, namely, stepwise forward selection (SFS) and genetic algorithm optimization combined with partial least squares regression for spectral data (GAPLSSP); four popular regression methods, namely, partial least squares (PLS), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), least squares support vector machine (LS-SVM), and Gaussian process regression (GPR). The comparative study indicates that, in general, pre-processing of spectral data can play a significant role in the calibration while wavelength selection plays a marginal role and the combination of certain pre-processing, wavelength selection, and nonlinear regression methods can achieve superior performance over traditional linear regression-based calibration.

AB - Near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy is being widely used in various fields ranging from pharmaceutics to the food industry for analyzing chemical and physical properties of the substances concerned. Its advantages over other analytical techniques include available physical interpretation of spectral data, nondestructive nature and high speed of measurements, and little or no need for sample preparation. The successful application of NIR spectroscopy relies on three main aspects: pre-processing of spectral data to eliminate nonlinear variations due to temperature, light scattering effects and many others, selection of those wavelengths that contribute useful information, and identification of suitable calibration models using linear/nonlinear regression . Several methods have been developed for each of these three aspects and many comparative studies of different methods exist for an individual aspect or some combinations. However, there is still a lack of comparative studies for the interactions among these three aspects, which can shed light on what role each aspect plays in the calibration and how to combine various methods of each aspect together to obtain the best calibration model. This paper aims to provide such a comparative study based on four benchmark data sets using three typical pre-processing methods, namely, orthogonal signal correction (OSC), extended multiplicative signal correction (EMSC) and optical path-length estimation and correction (OPLEC); two existing wavelength selection methods, namely, stepwise forward selection (SFS) and genetic algorithm optimization combined with partial least squares regression for spectral data (GAPLSSP); four popular regression methods, namely, partial least squares (PLS), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), least squares support vector machine (LS-SVM), and Gaussian process regression (GPR). The comparative study indicates that, in general, pre-processing of spectral data can play a significant role in the calibration while wavelength selection plays a marginal role and the combination of certain pre-processing, wavelength selection, and nonlinear regression methods can achieve superior performance over traditional linear regression-based calibration.

KW - near-infrared spectroscopy

KW - scatter correction

KW - pre-processing

KW - wavelength selection

KW - regression

KW - multivariate calibration

KW - support vector machines

KW - Gaussian process regression

KW - partial least squares regression

KW - PLS

U2 - 10.1177/0003702817694623

DO - 10.1177/0003702817694623

M3 - Article

VL - 71

SP - 1432

EP - 1446

JO - Applied Spectroscopy

T2 - Applied Spectroscopy

JF - Applied Spectroscopy

SN - 0003-7028

IS - 7

ER -